Place-Based Forest Agreements and Laws
Learning Topic
OVERVIEW
The National Forest Foundation and Bolle Center for People and Forests at the University of Montana held a symposium on June 8 and 9, 2010, focused on the growing interest in various landscape level approaches to management of our National Forests.
Throughout the country, divergent interests are collaborating about how they would like particular forests to be managed. Many of these proposals include provisions related to forest restoration, economic development, wilderness designation, and funding mechanisms, among others. Approaches include state-level principles, memorandums of agreement regarding how collaborative groups and federal agencies work together, landscape assessments that lead to on-the-ground work, and place-based legislation. Each initiative is different in significant ways, but all are searching for more durable, bottom-up, and pro-active solutions to national forest management.
For further information about the symposium, please contact:
- Karen DiBari at kdibari@nationalforests.org or (406) 830-3352
-
Martin Nie at martin.nie@cfc.umt.edu or (406)
243-6795
THE SYMPOSIUM
Representatives of twelve initiatives were invited to give short presentations about their effort at the Symposium. They were asked to specfically respond to these questions:
- Why did your stewardship effort form (what was the driving issue)?
- Who was/is at the table (just a broad overview of categories of participants)?
- What was/is the role of the Forest Service in your stewardship effort (participant/collaborator at the table, advisor to effort, “traditional” relationship of land management agency to the public, or other)?
- What are your effort’s main objectives?
- Why did your group choose the path or strategy toward achieving those objectives (administrative agreement, legislative proposal, change in interpretation of existing authorities, etc.)?
- 2010 Place-Based Forest Agreements & Laws Agenda (PDF)
- Place Based Forest Agreements and Laws Symposium 2010, Part 1 (Vimeo)
- * Opening comments by Bill Possiel and Mary Mitsos, National Forest Foundation and Martin Nie, Bolle Center for People & Forests * Northeast Washington Forestry Coalition, Lloyd McGee * Alabama Forest Restoration Initiative, Ray Vaughn * Clearwater Basin Collaborative, Jonathan Oppenheimer
- Place Based Forest Agreements and Laws Symposium 2010, Part 2 (Vimeo)
- * Beaverhead-Deerlodge Partnership, Bruce Farling * Four Forest Restoration Initiative, Ethan Aumack and Courtney Schultz * Blackfoot-Clearwater Landscape Stewardship Project, Gordy Sanders
- Place Based Forest Agreements and Laws Symposium 2010, Part 3 (Vimeo)
- * Montana Forest Restoration Committee, Marnie Criley * Oregon Eastside Forests Restoration, Old Growth Protection, and Jobs Acto fo 2009, Rick Brown * Lakeview Stewardship Group, Jim Walls
- Place Based Forest Agreements and Laws Symposium 2010, Part 4 (Vimeo)
- * Three Rivers Challenge, Rick Bass * Rocky Mountain Front Heritage Act, Jennifer Ferenstein * Wild Rivers Master Stewardship Agreement, Shane Jimerfield
BACKGROUND READING
Background documents and links are provided below. Their listing is for informational purposes and does not represent an endorsement. The list is far from complete. We hope that symposium panelists and participants will send us additional relevant documents for the committee to consider posting.
Defining Characteristics of Selected Place-Based Agreements and Laws
- Nie, M. "Place-Based National Forest Legislation and Agreements: Common Characteristics and Policy Recommendations," Environmental Law Reporter, 41 (2011): 10229-10246.
- Introduction
- Defining Characteristic #1: The Search for More Certainty in Forest Management
- Defining Characteristic #2: Landscape-Scale Restoration and Its Relationship to Rural Communities
- Defining Characteristic #3: Frustration with Status Quo and Desire for Change
- Explanatory Letter and Comparison Tables for Place-Based Forest Agreements and Laws Symposium (PDFs)
- Place-based forest law: Questions, opportunities presented by Montana Sen. Jon Tester's Forest Jobs and Recreation Act by Martin Nie
- Statement of Martin Nie to Senate Subcommittee on S. 1470 (PDF)
- Managing the National Forests through Place-Based Legislation (PDF) by Martin Nie and Michael Fiebig, Ecology Law Quarterly, Vol 37, no. 1 (2010): 1-52
- Senate Bill 1470
- Senate Bill 1470 - Senate Public Lands and Forests Subcommittee Hearing (includes written testimony and archived webcast)
- montanaforests.org
- Beaverhead Deerlodge Partnership
- Blackfoot-Clearwater Stewardship Project
- Three Rivers Challenge
- Montana’s Wilderness Drought: a Chronology compiled by Bill Schneider and posted on www.newwest.net
- Last Best Place Wildlands Campaign
- 4FRI Background
- 4FRI Landscape Strategy (PDF)
- 4FRI Collaborative Forest Landscape Restoration Program proposal (PDF)
- 4FRI - The Path Forward (PDF)
- Lakeview County Resources Initiative
- Long-Range Strategy for the Lakeview Federal Stewardship Unit
- Cultivating Common Ground
- Red Lodge Clearinghouse story on the Lakeview Stewardship Group
- Lakeview Stewardship Group MOU and Concurrence Letter for MOU (PDFs)
- www.newforestrycoalition.org
- Formalized Agreement between a Collaborative and the Forest Service - Northeast Washington Forestry Coalition MOU (PDF)
- Senator Ron Wyden's website and text of the bill
- Senate Public Lands and Forests Subcommittee Hearing on Senate Bill 2895 (includes written testimony and archived webcast)
- Oregon Wild's perspective on the bill
- www.savethefront.org
- Rocky Mountain Front Heritage Act Draft Proposal (PDF)
- Suggested Changes to Proposed Rocky Mountain Front Heritage Act Language (PDF)
- Restoring Sustainability: 2009 Annual Report of the Wild Rivers Master Stewardship Agreement
- Wild Rivers Master Stewardship Agreement
- Hope Mountain Stewardship Supplemental Project Agreement
Want to stay up-to-date on NFF Program news and learning opportunities? Sign up for our Listserv by following the link and entering your email address.